Direct-to-consumer genetic or over the counter testing emerged in the early 2000s as a means of allowing consumers to access information about their genetics without the involvement of a physician. While early models were popular with consumers, they were controversial in medical and regulatory circles.
In the January 2018 issue of Mayo Clinic Proceedings authors Megan Allyse Ph.D., David Robinson, Matthew Ferber Ph.D. and Richard Sharp Ph.D. trace the history of direct-to-consumer genetic testing, discuss its regulatory implications, and describe the emergence of a new hybrid model.
Direct-to-consumer testing — the early days
In 2007 the journal Science named human genetic variation the “breakthrough of the year” and direct-to-consumer companies were offering microarray panels for $1,000. Fast forward five years and the curious consumer could get a microarray panel for $99. Microarray refers to a microchip-based testing platform that allows high-volume, automated analysis of many pieces of DNA at once.
“Consumers liked the convenience of direct-to-consumer testing, the appeal of gaining access to their personal genetic information, and its promotion of preventive and individualized medicine,” says Dr. Allyse, a Mayo Clinic bioethicist, and lead-author of the paper.
However, critics quickly raised concerns about direct-to-consumer testing.
By 2011 the government began cracking down on the practices of direct-to-consumer testing companies. In 2013, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) ordered 23andMe to immediately discontinue marketing and sales of its health-related testing services until they received FDA authorization for these devices.
A new model emerges — direct-to-consumer 2.0
In 2015, 23andMe received FDA device approval for its carrier screen for hereditary Bloom syndrome. The FDA confirmed that 23andMe had submitted evidence demonstrating that members of the public were capable of correctly interpreting the test report at a 90 percent comprehension level.
“At the same time the FDA announced that it would classify direct-to-consumer genetic carrier screens as lower risk devices. This opened the way to testing for additional autosomal recessive conditions and signaled the FDA’s willingness to consider at least some forms of direct-to-consumer medical testing under the regulations,” says Dr. Allyse.
That same year Illumina one of the largest providers of genomic sequencing in the U.S. launched Helix, a personal genomics platform that utilizes a “sequence-once-query-often” model. Helix stores genomic information in a central database and allows its partners to develop various testing strategies that interrogate portions of genomic datasets for its customers. In 2017, the FDA approved the marketing of the first direct-to-consumer test for genetic health risk, 23andMe’s Personal Genome Service, which tests for 10 diseases or conditions, including Alzheimer’s risk, Parkinson’s disease, and hereditary thrombophilia.
“These emerging models of direct-to-consumer genetic testing attempt to strike a balance between the need to ensure consumer safety and the knowledge that personal genomic information is both highly desirable and potentially beneficial to some consumers,” says Dr. Allyse.
The future of direct-to-consumer testing
Dr. Allyse and colleagues speculate on several promising strategies to align the interests of the direct-to-consumer market and the practice of medicine:
The Mayo Clinic Center for Individualized Medicine continues to seek ways to apply the latest genomic, molecular and clinical science to personalized care for every individual, so patients receive the exact care they need — when they need it — and to address unmet needs of the patient.
Disclosure: The authors have no personal financial relationships to disclose. Mayo Clinic holds a commercial interest in Helix. There was no relationship between Helix and the contents of this paper.
Mayo Clinic Proceedings Symposium on Precision Medicine
This paper is part of the Mayo Clinic Proceedings Symposium on Precision Medicine, a series of articles that cover a wide range of topics in personalized medicine. Watch for an upcoming article in the symposium focusing on how personalized medicine and genomics are impacting patient care in the area of heritable cancers.
Read more about the ethical issues of home DNA kits
Learn more about biomedical ethics
Get the latest news from the Center for Individualized Medicine. Visit our blog, Facebook, LinkedIn or Twitter at @MayoClinicCIM.
Save the date for this year’s Individualizing Medicine Conference on Sept. 12-13.
Tags: #David Robinson, #DNA analysis, #Dr. Megan Allyse, #DTC genomic tests, #medical education, #Symposium on Precision Medicine, Bioethics, biomedical ethics, center for individualized medicine, Dr. Matthew Ferber, Dr. Richard Sharp, mayo clinic, Mayo Clinic Proceedings, medical research, Precision Medicine